The Comparison I Wish Someone Had Handed Me in 2019
When I first started managing our refrigeration and air-handling procurement budget, I assumed used equipment was the obvious cost play. Lower sticker price, faster availability, same OEM nameplate—what could go wrong?
Three budget overruns later, I stopped trusting my gut and started trusting my spreadsheet. Since 2019 I've tracked roughly $180,000 in cumulative spending across Howden compressors, centrifugal fans, and ammonia refrigeration components—both new and used. I've negotiated with 14 vendors and audited every invoice down to the freight line.
Here's the honest comparison, framed the way I actually evaluate it: not "which is cheaper" but "which is cheaper once you include everything I'll forget to budget for."
I'm comparing new OEM Howden equipment against used or refurbished Howden equipment across four dimensions that matter in industrial refrigeration: front-end cost vs. total cost of ownership, delivery certainty, parts availability, and performance risk. If you're evaluating a Howden fan company quote or a used ammonia compressor listing, this is the same lens I use.
Dimension 1: Sticker Price vs. Total Cost of Ownership
This is where my initial misjudgment bit me. Used Howden refrigeration equipment typically lists at 40–60% of new, which looks like an obvious win until the service history shows up.
In 2021, I bought a used Howden screw compressor package for $18,400. The new quote from the OEM authorized channel was around $46,000. I felt like a genius for roughly six weeks—until the pre-commissioning inspection flagged a worn rotor coating and a missing oil cooler service record. Rotor recoating ran $6,200. The cooler assembly replacement was $3,100. Freight back and forth added another $900. We were into that "bargain" for $28,600 before it moved a single cubic meter of refrigerant.
But here's where the comparison gets interesting, and where the conventional "new is always safer" wisdom falls apart. My colleague in our food-processing division bought a refurbished Howden NH3 compressor through a certified rebuild shop—full teardown, new bearings, documented test run—for $22,000 against a $52,000 new unit. Eighteen months in, zero unplanned downtime.
The difference wasn't new vs. used. It was documented refurbishment vs. undocumented asset. The causation runs the other way from what most people assume: the certification process doesn't guarantee reliability, reliable shops tend to be the ones that bother certifying. Equipment that arrives with a full inspection dossier tends to perform better because the seller had something to lose by hiding defects.
What the numbers actually showed
- New OEM Howden unit: $46,000, 24-month warranty, commissioning support included.
- Used, undocumented: $18,400 + $10,200 in remediation = $28,600 effective, no warranty.
- Certified refurbished: $22,000, 12-month limited warranty, documented test run.
The certified refurbished option delivered roughly 85% of the new-unit performance profile at 48% of the cost. That's the one I'd repeat.
Dimension 2: Delivery Certainty vs. Price
If you've read anything I've written before, you know my position: in a deadline situation, the certainty of delivery is worth a premium. This is where used Howden equipment gets complicated.
In March 2024 we had a cold-storage expansion with a hard commissioning date tied to a $15,000/day throughput contract. We needed an additional air compressor and a backup fan set. New equipment had a 14-week lead time. A used Howden fan package was available in three weeks from a regional dealer.
Everything I'd read about paying for expedited new equipment said lead time was the biggest risk. In practice, the used route carried a different risk: the dealer "would probably" have the units ready. That's the phrase that has cost me the most money over six years—probably.
We paid roughly 18% more for new equipment sourced through a channel partner who could commit to a dated delivery window with penalty clauses. The used option was $6,400 cheaper on paper, but the gap between "probably three weeks" and "confirmed 19 business days" is exactly the gap that kills cold-storage startups.
Here's the uncomfortable part: I've also been burned by new-equipment lead times slipping. OEMs miss dates too. The lesson isn't "new is more reliable." It's that contracted certainty is worth paying for regardless of equipment condition—and used dealers are less likely to sign delivery penalties because they don't control the refurbishment queue.
Dimension 3: Parts Availability and Serviceability
This dimension surprised me. I assumed used Howden equipment would be a parts nightmare. In practice, Howden's installed base is large enough that common wear parts—bearings, seals, gaskets, coupling elements—are stocked by multiple aftermarket suppliers.
What is not interchangeable is control systems and electronic modules. Used units from pre-2015 vintages often run proprietary controllers that the OEM has moved past. When a control board fails on a used unit, you're often looking at a retrofit, not a replacement. That retrofit runs $4,000–$9,000 depending on the unit class, with lead times measured in months.
Newer used Howden equipment—say, 2018 or later—tends to be more serviceable because the control platforms are still supported. If you're evaluating used refrigeration equipment, the manufacturing year matters more than the hours on the meter. A 2019 unit with 30,000 hours is often a better bet than a 2013 unit with 12,000 hours, because the electrical architecture is still in the OEM's support window.
One correction worth making
I said earlier that older used units are "parts nightmares." Actually, that's overstated. Mechanical parts are widely available across vintages. It's specifically the control and monitoring electronics where the support gap bites. Worth being precise about, because it changes how you should inspect a used unit—focus your diligence on the controller and instrumentation, not the mechanical condition.
Dimension 4: Performance Risk and Efficiency Claims
Used equipment listings love efficiency claims. Be deeply suspicious of unverified ones. A compressor that ran at 92% efficiency in 2018 may be running at 84% today—that's a real cost delta on a unit that runs continuously.
The practical fix: require a witnessed performance test before purchase on any used Howden unit above ~$15,000. Certified rebuild shops will usually accommodate this. Private sellers usually won't, which tells you something.
New equipment isn't immune either. I've seen new-unit efficiency claims that were measured under ideal conditions and never replicated in our actual operating envelope. The right move is to specify performance guarantees in the contract with test conditions matched to your process—not to trust a datasheet.
One more thing I want to flag: the used market for Howden equipment has real variability because Howden has been through multiple ownership changes and product-line reorganizations. Serial-number verification through the OEM support channel is worth the 20 minutes—I've caught one misrepresented unit that way and saved myself a $30,000 headache.
So Which Should You Buy?
Here's the honest, scenario-specific answer. I can't tell you new is better or used is better—that depends entirely on what you're optimizing for.
Buy new when: the equipment is on a critical path with a hard deadline; the unit is a control-intensive platform; you need warranty coverage for capital planning purposes; or the application is safety-critical (ammonia refrigeration in occupied spaces qualifies). In those cases the premium is buying certainty, and certainty is worth more than the discount.
Buy certified refurbished when: you have a buffer in your schedule, the unit class is mechanically simple (fans, blowers, standard compressors), and the rebuild shop will provide a documented test run and limited warranty. This is where the TCO math is most likely to work in your favor.
Avoid undocumented used equipment entirely unless you have internal engineering capacity to inspect and remediate. The math only works if you price in the remediation, and most buyers don't.
This approach worked for us, but I should note our context: we're a mid-size B2B operation with predictable maintenance staffing and a service partner who can respond within 24 hours. If you're running a single-site operation with no in-house maintenance, the used calculus shifts hard toward new—because a failed used unit isn't a repair, it's a shutdown.
And one last boundary: I can only speak to ammonia and standard industrial refrigeration applications. If you're dealing with food-grade CO2 systems or specialty gas handling, the parts and certification landscape is different enough that I wouldn't trust my spreadsheet to translate.
Prices in this article reflect our actual invoices between 2019 and 2025. Used equipment pricing varies widely by region and condition—verify current market rates before budgeting.